GameSpy.com
- [80/100] Review of GameCube version by Craig Wessel. "If you're a baseball fan, you'll love the attention to detail in this game."
- http://archive.gamespy.com/reviews/january02/allstarbaseball2002/

All Game Guide
- Reviewed by Tom Carroll [4/5]. "Leveraging great depth, wonderfully simple play mechanics, and competent graphic touches, this game should last as long as an official baseball season." Also offers description and control instructions. [PlayStati
- http://www.allgame.com/cg/agg.dll?p=agg&SQL=GRH||||25594

GameSpot
- Reviewed by: Shane Satterfield, score 6.5. "Features a wealth of gameplay modes and an impressive amount of on-field control." [GameCube]
- http://www.gamespot.com/gamecube/sports/allstarbaseball2002/

Sports Gaming Network
- Reviewed by: James Smith, score 78/100. "A decent, but not great, baseball title." [PlayStation 2]
- http://www.sports-gaming.com/baseball/all_star_baseball_2002/review_ps2.shtml

GamePro
- Reviewed by: Jake the Snake, score 4.5/5. "The cursor-style pitching and batting interfaces work great." (PlayStation 2)
- http://www.gamepro.com/sony/ps2/games/reviews/12444.shtml

IGN.com
- Reviewed by Matt Casamassina [6.8/10]. "...[A] fun, but unpolished simulation..." Includes screen shots. [GameCube]
- http://cube.ign.com/articles/166/166560p1.html

IGN
- Reviewed by: David Zdyrko, score 8.4/10. "It's not perfect, but this is the best overall game of hardball that you'll find on PS2." (PlayStation 2)
- http://ps2.ign.com/articles/164/164320p1.html

PlanetPS2
- Reviewed by: Josh Hiscock, score 80/100. "Perhaps the biggest flaw, however, isn't a flaw so much as a disappointing omission." (PlayStation 2)
- http://www.planetps2.com/features/reviews/2001/asb2k2/